SAIIER 2014:Removing Reading and Writing Difficulty: Difference between revisions
(Created page with "{{SAIIER 2014|previous=SAIIER 2014:Portfolio Assessment for Integral Education|current=Removing Reading and Writing Difficulty|next=SAIIER 2014:Summer Camp}}") |
No edit summary |
||
| (2 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
{{SAIIER 2014|previous=[[SAIIER 2014:Portfolio Assessment for Integral Education|Portfolio Assessment for Integral Education]]|current=Removing Reading and Writing Difficulty|next=[[SAIIER 2014:Summer Camp|Summer Camp]]}} | {{SAIIER 2014|previous=[[SAIIER 2014:Portfolio Assessment for Integral Education|Portfolio Assessment for Integral Education]]|current=Removing Reading and Writing Difficulty|next=[[SAIIER 2014:Summer Camp|Summer Camp]]}} | ||
__NOTOC__ | |||
===Objective=== | |||
[[Year::2014| ]]Removal of the reading and writing difficulties of 21 students at [[Entity::Isai Ambalam School]]. | |||
===Details of the difficulty=== | |||
====Difficulty for 19 students==== | |||
[[Language learning::Tamil| ]]The 1st group of students had difficulties in reading, writing and remembering 40 Tamil letters and lesser difficulties in 20 letters; the 2nd group of students had difficulties in 40 letters and lesser difficulties in 40 letters; and the 3rd group had difficulties in 40 letters and lesser difficulties in 60 letters. All these students had difficulties in Vowel-Consonant-Combination letters. It was because the 64 Vowel-Consonant-Combination letters had 1 or 2 additional vowel symbols ெ, ே, ா, used to distinguish between the sounds “எ” (short /e/), “ஏ” (long /e/), “ஒ” (short /o/), “ஓ” (long /oa/), “ ா” used to distinguish between short and long vowel sounds in Vowel-Consonant-Combinations. | |||
They also had problems in Vowel-Consonant-Combination letters with short /oo/ sound as in ‘cook’, ‘book’ and with long /OO/ sound as in ‘tooth’, ‘booth’. These sounds are represented by single letters like சு, பு, வு, யு and சூ, பூ, வூ, யூ; or கு, டு, மு, ரு, ழு, ளு and மூ, டூ, ரூ, ழூ, ளூ; or ணு, து, நு, லு, று, னு and ணூ, தூ, நூ, லூ, றூ, னூ. Here the difficulty is that no common symbol is used to represent these sounds; the symbols used were different and of three kinds. | |||
Further they also faced difficulties in hearing clearly and distinguishing between the sounds of 7 Consonant letters; they sounds were similar but with a slight difference. They were: ல, ள, ந, ன, ண, ர, ற (ல and ள, ன, ந and ண, ர and ற); the sounds of the letters in each of these groups are similar and the letters are different They found it difficult to distinguish between these sounds and hence to remember the letters. | |||
====Difficulty for 2 slightly dyslexic students==== | |||
The two dyslexic students are generally cheerful and not at all gloomy. They are good-humored. “S” has a scientific termperment and is dynamic. “B” is sweet and is trying her level best in reading and writing well. In spite of it their progress is hampered because they found it difficult to read and express themselves in writing. | |||
===Remedial Activities that were decided upon and given to them=== | |||
Due to various reasons these students did not have adequate opportunities to use these letters in reading or writing contexts. If ever they had got such opportunities they were in a small measure, not in such a measure that any difficulty felt by them in remembering and reading were got rid of permanently. For these students these activities were deliberately designed so that they practiced reading and writing all these letters with involvement and joy. | |||
====For the 19 students==== | |||
The remedial activities provided them with repeated opportunities for reading and writing so that they saw all the letters with symbols in many contexts and in many combinations of words. Following were the activities given to them: | |||
#Matching activity. | |||
#Finding out the mistakes in the words in sentences and correcting them, and then writing the full sentences correctly. | |||
#Finding out the missing letters in the words. | |||
#Changing the words starting with a short vowel to words starting with a long vowel. | |||
#Listening to and writing down the words dictated by the teacher. | |||
#Reading the letter hand-written by the teacher. | |||
#Circling the words told by the teacher in the newspaper | |||
#Slide game. | |||
All the letters involved in these activities are Vowel-Consonant-Combination Words. | |||
====For the two slightly dyslexic students==== | |||
For dealing with this difficulty we did not use any elaborate process for a long duration which is normally adopted in many places. From the Internet we learnt about the methodology discovered by Ronald Davis for ridding oneself of this difficulty. Davis himself was afflicted with dyslexia till he was 38 and suffered a lot in life. In spite of it he became an engineer and was doing well in his profession. When he was 38 years he was thinking about his dyslexic ailment and was trying to see things with different perspectives like deliberately seeing things with crossed eyes. At some point during this activity he found out that he was seeing the letters in words correctly and in the right sequence. He made efforts to see from this perspective and managed to get that perspective consciously. Straightaway he went to the library came across a book by Mark Twain and managed to read the entire book at one goes. It was the first time he had managed to read in such a way. Later he explored this process and found out that he had come across the right perspective by locating his real mind’s eye. He discovered that for some reason his perspective had got disoriented and locating this mind’s eye and seeing him made him get back his right orientation. His further exploration led him to see the necessity of removing all the activities that confuse him in this process and made him disoriented. Practice of making the alphabets and words with clay enabled him to be rid of any confusions that intervened in his perspective and made it disoriented. He systematised this activity and designed a methodology to cure dyslexia. | |||
His methodology consisted of two parts. One was to enable the dyslexically affected person get back the correct orientation from seeing from his mind’s eyes. It is called the Davis Orientation process. In his institutes he trained trainers in helping the dyslexic persons locate their mind’s eyes and rightly orient their perspective. The second was Symbol Mastery Process for sufficient duration so that no confusion can intervene and disrupt this orientation. | |||
We wanted to try this methodology for our two dyslexic students. We bought his Davis Orientation and Symbol Mastery Kit and learnt about the details of his method. As Davis considered his method applicable only to people above 12 years it could be tried with "S" only. Further Davis considered this orientation process should be performed only by the trainers trained in his institute. In India we read about only two such trainers in North India and found the cost of using them prohibitive. Sanjeev Ranganthan, who is capable of imparting visuliation techniques to others and with a certain experience in it, came forward to try it. For "S" the Orientation Technique of the Davis Correction Programme was applied by Sanjeev Ranganathan. Even though it could not be applied to “B” who was just 9 years old, Symbol Mastery techniques were used for her effectively by using Plasticine Clay. | |||
Below is given the description by Sanjeev Ranganathan, of how the Orientation Technique was used for "S". | |||
<div style="padding-left:20px; font-style:italic;"> | |||
'''My use of Davis Orientation process for "S" | |||
"S" is an intelligent and responsible child. He, however, found himself struggling with reading writing and even the simplest algebraic equations. In such situations he either froze or made up his own situation/words, etc. His writing skills were quite weak and he often mixes up letters and their orientation even though he is in 7th grade. He is, however,able to type much quicker and with fewer mistakes than his peers.He took significant time to understand abstract equations, but was able to implement procedures almost once he has mastered them. He displayed great patience in what he did. | |||
He noticed that he found himself in a state of confusion sometimes, especially when he felt under stress e.g. during examinations. Due to the factors mentioned above his teachers felt that "S" could have some form of disorientation/dyslexia. The school received materials related to the Davis dyslexia kit and Sanjeev with observation from Kavitha followed the Davis Orientation/Alignment procedure in the kit. | |||
Sanjeev took permission from "S" to try out a procedure that might help him get clarity when he feels confused or stuck. Sanjeev then along with "S" went over the feeling of release (fist closing exercise) to help him be at ease and be capable of remembering what a calm feeling feels like.To assess which orientation procedure is to be used Sanjeev used the Perceptual Ability Assessment. This was done by visualization of a piece of cake in the student’s hand, giving it characteristics and then viewing it from different vantage points. Sanjeev realized that "S" was very creative and added much detail to his cake, but the description of shape and cross section from different points of view were not consistent with what is normally expected. | |||
This prompted the use of the Alignment by visualizing yourself standing behind when you are sitting down and creating a mind’s eye that looked from beyond and above you. This process is supposed to help to orient things from the traditional point of view and avoid confusion. "S" seemed comfortable with the process though he mentioned that everything seemed normal like before. | |||
"S" uses the release technique, but does not seem to utilize the reorientation procedure that went with the release as often. "S"’s teachers, however, have seen a marked improvement in his reading and abstraction skills. He seems to have developed a knack of being able to catch himself when he is about to make a mistake and his ability to grasp new procedures is significantly faster. These have also resulted in improved academic achievement in the last year. It is, of course, a question even to us how much the alignment technique contributed to this improvement. | |||
</div> | |||
===Results=== | |||
====For the 19 students==== | |||
Among the 19 students, for 8 students the difficulties have been removed. They are now able to read, write and recognise the letters. They are also able to read the books faster than before. | |||
Out of the 13 remaining students, for 3 students 75% of the difficulties had been removed. They need one more month continuing with such activities to complete the process and to become normal like the above mentioned 8 students. | |||
For the remaining 8 students, only 40% of the difficulties had been removed. For various reasons their attendance was very irregular. Still we feel confident that 3 more months of continuing the present process and regular attendance can complete the removal of their difficulties in reading and writing. We intend to take necessary steps to improve their attendance. | |||
====For the 2 slightly dyslexic students==== | |||
90% of the difficulties had been removed for "S", But still “B” has learning difficulties. As she is enthused on seeing her progress, she is becoming more involved in doing these activities, and wants to be completely free of her difficulties. For that she needs 3 more months of such activities which we hope she is fully ready to do. | |||
*[http://wiki.auroville.org.in/w/images/7/7a/2013_Removing_Reading_and_Writing_Difficulty_-_Appendix_1.pdf Appendix 1: "The Cause of Dyslexia: Anatomy of a Learning Disability" by Ronald D. Davis, 1985] | |||
*[http://wiki.auroville.org.in/w/images/e/eb/2013_Removing_Reading_and_Writing_Difficulty_-_Appendix_2.pdf Appendix 2: "Davis® Dyslexia Correction: A Brief Explanation" by Abigail Marshall, 2008] | |||
<hovergallery> | |||
File:2014 Removing reading difficulties 1.jpg | |||
File:2014 Removing reading difficulties 2.jpg | |||
File:2014 Removing reading difficulties 3.jpg | |||
File:2014 Removing reading difficulties 4.jpg | |||
</hovergallery> | |||
<br> | |||
[[Category:Reports 2014]] | |||
Latest revision as of 08:55, 12 January 2021
Portfolio Assessment for Integral Education |
Summer Camp | |
| Removing Reading and Writing Difficulty | ||
Objective
Removal of the reading and writing difficulties of 21 students at Entity::Isai Ambalam School.
Details of the difficulty
Difficulty for 19 students
The 1st group of students had difficulties in reading, writing and remembering 40 Tamil letters and lesser difficulties in 20 letters; the 2nd group of students had difficulties in 40 letters and lesser difficulties in 40 letters; and the 3rd group had difficulties in 40 letters and lesser difficulties in 60 letters. All these students had difficulties in Vowel-Consonant-Combination letters. It was because the 64 Vowel-Consonant-Combination letters had 1 or 2 additional vowel symbols ெ, ே, ா, used to distinguish between the sounds “எ” (short /e/), “ஏ” (long /e/), “ஒ” (short /o/), “ஓ” (long /oa/), “ ா” used to distinguish between short and long vowel sounds in Vowel-Consonant-Combinations.
They also had problems in Vowel-Consonant-Combination letters with short /oo/ sound as in ‘cook’, ‘book’ and with long /OO/ sound as in ‘tooth’, ‘booth’. These sounds are represented by single letters like சு, பு, வு, யு and சூ, பூ, வூ, யூ; or கு, டு, மு, ரு, ழு, ளு and மூ, டூ, ரூ, ழூ, ளூ; or ணு, து, நு, லு, று, னு and ணூ, தூ, நூ, லூ, றூ, னூ. Here the difficulty is that no common symbol is used to represent these sounds; the symbols used were different and of three kinds.
Further they also faced difficulties in hearing clearly and distinguishing between the sounds of 7 Consonant letters; they sounds were similar but with a slight difference. They were: ல, ள, ந, ன, ண, ர, ற (ல and ள, ன, ந and ண, ர and ற); the sounds of the letters in each of these groups are similar and the letters are different They found it difficult to distinguish between these sounds and hence to remember the letters.
Difficulty for 2 slightly dyslexic students
The two dyslexic students are generally cheerful and not at all gloomy. They are good-humored. “S” has a scientific termperment and is dynamic. “B” is sweet and is trying her level best in reading and writing well. In spite of it their progress is hampered because they found it difficult to read and express themselves in writing.
Remedial Activities that were decided upon and given to them
Due to various reasons these students did not have adequate opportunities to use these letters in reading or writing contexts. If ever they had got such opportunities they were in a small measure, not in such a measure that any difficulty felt by them in remembering and reading were got rid of permanently. For these students these activities were deliberately designed so that they practiced reading and writing all these letters with involvement and joy.
For the 19 students
The remedial activities provided them with repeated opportunities for reading and writing so that they saw all the letters with symbols in many contexts and in many combinations of words. Following were the activities given to them:
- Matching activity.
- Finding out the mistakes in the words in sentences and correcting them, and then writing the full sentences correctly.
- Finding out the missing letters in the words.
- Changing the words starting with a short vowel to words starting with a long vowel.
- Listening to and writing down the words dictated by the teacher.
- Reading the letter hand-written by the teacher.
- Circling the words told by the teacher in the newspaper
- Slide game.
All the letters involved in these activities are Vowel-Consonant-Combination Words.
For the two slightly dyslexic students
For dealing with this difficulty we did not use any elaborate process for a long duration which is normally adopted in many places. From the Internet we learnt about the methodology discovered by Ronald Davis for ridding oneself of this difficulty. Davis himself was afflicted with dyslexia till he was 38 and suffered a lot in life. In spite of it he became an engineer and was doing well in his profession. When he was 38 years he was thinking about his dyslexic ailment and was trying to see things with different perspectives like deliberately seeing things with crossed eyes. At some point during this activity he found out that he was seeing the letters in words correctly and in the right sequence. He made efforts to see from this perspective and managed to get that perspective consciously. Straightaway he went to the library came across a book by Mark Twain and managed to read the entire book at one goes. It was the first time he had managed to read in such a way. Later he explored this process and found out that he had come across the right perspective by locating his real mind’s eye. He discovered that for some reason his perspective had got disoriented and locating this mind’s eye and seeing him made him get back his right orientation. His further exploration led him to see the necessity of removing all the activities that confuse him in this process and made him disoriented. Practice of making the alphabets and words with clay enabled him to be rid of any confusions that intervened in his perspective and made it disoriented. He systematised this activity and designed a methodology to cure dyslexia.
His methodology consisted of two parts. One was to enable the dyslexically affected person get back the correct orientation from seeing from his mind’s eyes. It is called the Davis Orientation process. In his institutes he trained trainers in helping the dyslexic persons locate their mind’s eyes and rightly orient their perspective. The second was Symbol Mastery Process for sufficient duration so that no confusion can intervene and disrupt this orientation.
We wanted to try this methodology for our two dyslexic students. We bought his Davis Orientation and Symbol Mastery Kit and learnt about the details of his method. As Davis considered his method applicable only to people above 12 years it could be tried with "S" only. Further Davis considered this orientation process should be performed only by the trainers trained in his institute. In India we read about only two such trainers in North India and found the cost of using them prohibitive. Sanjeev Ranganthan, who is capable of imparting visuliation techniques to others and with a certain experience in it, came forward to try it. For "S" the Orientation Technique of the Davis Correction Programme was applied by Sanjeev Ranganathan. Even though it could not be applied to “B” who was just 9 years old, Symbol Mastery techniques were used for her effectively by using Plasticine Clay.
Below is given the description by Sanjeev Ranganathan, of how the Orientation Technique was used for "S".
My use of Davis Orientation process for "S"
"S" is an intelligent and responsible child. He, however, found himself struggling with reading writing and even the simplest algebraic equations. In such situations he either froze or made up his own situation/words, etc. His writing skills were quite weak and he often mixes up letters and their orientation even though he is in 7th grade. He is, however,able to type much quicker and with fewer mistakes than his peers.He took significant time to understand abstract equations, but was able to implement procedures almost once he has mastered them. He displayed great patience in what he did.
He noticed that he found himself in a state of confusion sometimes, especially when he felt under stress e.g. during examinations. Due to the factors mentioned above his teachers felt that "S" could have some form of disorientation/dyslexia. The school received materials related to the Davis dyslexia kit and Sanjeev with observation from Kavitha followed the Davis Orientation/Alignment procedure in the kit.
Sanjeev took permission from "S" to try out a procedure that might help him get clarity when he feels confused or stuck. Sanjeev then along with "S" went over the feeling of release (fist closing exercise) to help him be at ease and be capable of remembering what a calm feeling feels like.To assess which orientation procedure is to be used Sanjeev used the Perceptual Ability Assessment. This was done by visualization of a piece of cake in the student’s hand, giving it characteristics and then viewing it from different vantage points. Sanjeev realized that "S" was very creative and added much detail to his cake, but the description of shape and cross section from different points of view were not consistent with what is normally expected.
This prompted the use of the Alignment by visualizing yourself standing behind when you are sitting down and creating a mind’s eye that looked from beyond and above you. This process is supposed to help to orient things from the traditional point of view and avoid confusion. "S" seemed comfortable with the process though he mentioned that everything seemed normal like before.
"S" uses the release technique, but does not seem to utilize the reorientation procedure that went with the release as often. "S"’s teachers, however, have seen a marked improvement in his reading and abstraction skills. He seems to have developed a knack of being able to catch himself when he is about to make a mistake and his ability to grasp new procedures is significantly faster. These have also resulted in improved academic achievement in the last year. It is, of course, a question even to us how much the alignment technique contributed to this improvement.
Results
For the 19 students
Among the 19 students, for 8 students the difficulties have been removed. They are now able to read, write and recognise the letters. They are also able to read the books faster than before.
Out of the 13 remaining students, for 3 students 75% of the difficulties had been removed. They need one more month continuing with such activities to complete the process and to become normal like the above mentioned 8 students.
For the remaining 8 students, only 40% of the difficulties had been removed. For various reasons their attendance was very irregular. Still we feel confident that 3 more months of continuing the present process and regular attendance can complete the removal of their difficulties in reading and writing. We intend to take necessary steps to improve their attendance.
For the 2 slightly dyslexic students
90% of the difficulties had been removed for "S", But still “B” has learning difficulties. As she is enthused on seeing her progress, she is becoming more involved in doing these activities, and wants to be completely free of her difficulties. For that she needs 3 more months of such activities which we hope she is fully ready to do.
- Appendix 1: "The Cause of Dyslexia: Anatomy of a Learning Disability" by Ronald D. Davis, 1985
- Appendix 2: "Davis® Dyslexia Correction: A Brief Explanation" by Abigail Marshall, 2008