SAIIER Staff Quarters Design Selection Process: Difference between revisions
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
| Line 6: | Line 6: | ||
[[File:Entry1 Sheet4.png|300px]] | [[File:Entry1 Sheet4.png|300px]] | ||
</div> | </div> | ||
<u>Jury feedback</u> | |||
Pros: | |||
*The design breaks the '4 blocks' concept given in the brief, while retaining the essential requirements. | |||
*The “staggered” arrangement of houses and entrances promotes less mutual disturbance and allows community spaces. | |||
*The layout gives the opportunity to change which site accesses are used, allowing flexibility if there is a change in this regard. | |||
*The parking is kept at the outer periphery of the site instead of coming inside. | |||
*If the main access is decided upon the spacing between the blocks can be improved substantially. | |||
*High areas under barrel vaults in the top floors. | |||
Cons: | |||
*The design is heavy with walls. | |||
*The community spaces border the bedrooms, the noise of which could create tension. | |||
*Size and position of windows in regard to orientation and privacy (community spaces) not optimal. | |||
*Overhangs of windows below the top barrels and their operation not solved. | |||
*“Staggered section” of one block to create mezzanine for community activities, and how it relates to the outdoor community space, is not clear. | |||
Suggested modifications for second round: | |||
*The buildings could be opened up in some places, keeping in mind the orientation. | |||
*Positioning and distances of blocks to be adapted to access from one side only. | |||
*Windows or netting below top vaults to be properly protected (driving rain). | |||
*Community space within block to be clarified. | |||
====Entry #2==== | |||
<u>Jury feedback</u> | |||
Pros: | |||
*The peaked roofs on the top floors serve several good functions: dispersing heat, allowing light to the interiors, providing community space, and cooling the roof. | |||
*Option 2A shows the clearest plan amongst the given alternatives. | |||
Cons: | |||
*Many arrangements and options (for blocks as well as site), not significantly different from each other, none of them with inevitability or ‘convincingness’. The architect doesn’t propose a specific design with confidence, which gives the client the responsibility of choosing . | |||
*With such uncertainty in block placement, the jury can tell neither how the buildings would relate to the community spaces nor influence each other. | |||
*Option 2B creates impossible conditions to live in. | |||
*It is not clear whether or not there has been consideration given about orientation. | |||
*The peaked roofs, in spite of their advantages, jeopardise privacy of the areas below, since the roof is accessed by the public. | |||
====Entry #3==== | ====Entry #3==== | ||
| Line 14: | Line 60: | ||
[[File:Entry3 Sheet4.png|400px]] | [[File:Entry3 Sheet4.png|400px]] | ||
</div> | </div> | ||
<u>Jury feedback</u> | |||
Pros: | |||
*The axonometric view of the 4 houses (on first glance) give a very pleasing impression. | |||
*The shutters allow flexibility according to use and according to weather and climate conditions. | |||
*The design gives very generous space for circulation in each block (though only benefiting the upstairs flats). | |||
*The large ground floor veranda could be enclosed into the house in the future, allowing easy expansion of usable space (but has to be pre-financed in the beginning). | |||
Cons: | |||
*Large glass walls - even when shuttered - would be ill-suited to this climate for much of the year. | |||
*Access to the first floor is concentrated on the small uncomfortable spiral staircase although there would be ample space for a proper staircase. | |||
*The staircase is not protected from the elements, and would be dangerous during rains. | |||
*Orientation seems to be neglected in the design. | |||
*Common spaces are positioned next to glass walls; this, even when shuttered, creates privacy problems. | |||
*The blocks as designed would need more space around them to coexist without mutual disturbances (visual and acoustic). | |||
*The first house is disadvantaged, since the way the parking is sited all residents would have to go around it to enter the site. | |||
*No veranda or sit-out for the small flats. | |||
*All entrances on ground floor and first floor have no cover. | |||
*The structural system is ambiguous: on one side it seems to consist of pillars, on the other side of load bearing walls. | |||
*It would be difficult to bring down the waste pipes from the FF bathrooms without causing acoustical disturbances. | |||
*Probably a costly solution. | |||
====Entry #4==== | ====Entry #4==== | ||
Revision as of 06:46, 16 December 2015
Entry #1
Jury feedback
Pros:
- The design breaks the '4 blocks' concept given in the brief, while retaining the essential requirements.
- The “staggered” arrangement of houses and entrances promotes less mutual disturbance and allows community spaces.
- The layout gives the opportunity to change which site accesses are used, allowing flexibility if there is a change in this regard.
- The parking is kept at the outer periphery of the site instead of coming inside.
- If the main access is decided upon the spacing between the blocks can be improved substantially.
- High areas under barrel vaults in the top floors.
Cons:
- The design is heavy with walls.
- The community spaces border the bedrooms, the noise of which could create tension.
- Size and position of windows in regard to orientation and privacy (community spaces) not optimal.
- Overhangs of windows below the top barrels and their operation not solved.
- “Staggered section” of one block to create mezzanine for community activities, and how it relates to the outdoor community space, is not clear.
Suggested modifications for second round:
- The buildings could be opened up in some places, keeping in mind the orientation.
- Positioning and distances of blocks to be adapted to access from one side only.
- Windows or netting below top vaults to be properly protected (driving rain).
- Community space within block to be clarified.
Entry #2
Jury feedback
Pros:
- The peaked roofs on the top floors serve several good functions: dispersing heat, allowing light to the interiors, providing community space, and cooling the roof.
- Option 2A shows the clearest plan amongst the given alternatives.
Cons:
- Many arrangements and options (for blocks as well as site), not significantly different from each other, none of them with inevitability or ‘convincingness’. The architect doesn’t propose a specific design with confidence, which gives the client the responsibility of choosing .
- With such uncertainty in block placement, the jury can tell neither how the buildings would relate to the community spaces nor influence each other.
- Option 2B creates impossible conditions to live in.
- It is not clear whether or not there has been consideration given about orientation.
- The peaked roofs, in spite of their advantages, jeopardise privacy of the areas below, since the roof is accessed by the public.
Entry #3
Jury feedback
Pros:
- The axonometric view of the 4 houses (on first glance) give a very pleasing impression.
- The shutters allow flexibility according to use and according to weather and climate conditions.
- The design gives very generous space for circulation in each block (though only benefiting the upstairs flats).
- The large ground floor veranda could be enclosed into the house in the future, allowing easy expansion of usable space (but has to be pre-financed in the beginning).
Cons:
- Large glass walls - even when shuttered - would be ill-suited to this climate for much of the year.
- Access to the first floor is concentrated on the small uncomfortable spiral staircase although there would be ample space for a proper staircase.
- The staircase is not protected from the elements, and would be dangerous during rains.
- Orientation seems to be neglected in the design.
- Common spaces are positioned next to glass walls; this, even when shuttered, creates privacy problems.
- The blocks as designed would need more space around them to coexist without mutual disturbances (visual and acoustic).
- The first house is disadvantaged, since the way the parking is sited all residents would have to go around it to enter the site.
- No veranda or sit-out for the small flats.
- All entrances on ground floor and first floor have no cover.
- The structural system is ambiguous: on one side it seems to consist of pillars, on the other side of load bearing walls.
- It would be difficult to bring down the waste pipes from the FF bathrooms without causing acoustical disturbances.
- Probably a costly solution.