Talk:Farms: Difference between revisions
(New page: WHY ORGANICALLY GROWN FOOD IS MORE EXPENSIVE THAN THAT PRODUCED USING CONVENTIONAL FARMING METHODS 1. Generally production costs of organic farming are higher because the techniques of ...) |
No edit summary |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
WHY ORGANICALLY GROWN FOOD IS MORE EXPENSIVE THAN THAT PRODUCED USING CONVENTIONAL FARMING METHODS | WHY ORGANICALLY GROWN FOOD IS MORE EXPENSIVE THAN THAT PRODUCED USING CONVENTIONAL FARMING METHODS | ||
<br> | |||
1. Generally production costs of organic farming are higher because the techniques of organic/sustainable farming (see below for description of differences between modern and organic farming) are very labour intensive. Jobs like weeding and compost making are difficult to mechanise. The extra volumes of organic fertilizers needed add to the cost. Whereas a conventional farmer will use 80 –100kg of fertilizer per acre, all of which has been produced in the factory, the organic farmer will need 5 tons of compost per acre, all of which will need to be made on the farm. This means that labour costs are much higher for organic farmers. Organic farmers conserve the soil and water and this takes more labour (in the case of soil) and more infrastructure (various types of irrigation) in the case of water. | |||
1. Generally production costs of organic farming are higher because the techniques of organic/sustainable farming (see below for description of differences between modern and organic farming) are very labour intensive. Jobs like weeding and compost making are difficult to mechanise. The extra volumes of organic fertilizers needed add to the cost. Whereas a conventional farmer will use 80 –100kg of fertilizer per acre, all of which has been produced in the factory, the organic farmer will need 5 tons of compost per acre, all of which will need to be made on the farm. This means that labour costs are much higher for organic farmers. Organic farmers conserve the soil and water and this takes more labour (in the case of soil) and more infrastructure (various types of irrigation) in the case of water. | |||
2. Production is generally lower on organic farms than on conventional farms especially in the beginning. Research in Buddha Garden and elsewhere shows that plants on organic farms can produce equivalent amounts to those on conventional farms, but the labour needed to keep production at a high level (especially in sustaining the soil) is much more. | 2. Production is generally lower on organic farms than on conventional farms especially in the beginning. Research in Buddha Garden and elsewhere shows that plants on organic farms can produce equivalent amounts to those on conventional farms, but the labour needed to keep production at a high level (especially in sustaining the soil) is much more. | ||
| Line 9: | Line 9: | ||
3. Organic farms in Auroville the farms are on the whole small and therefore cannot take advantage of mechanisation and the associated economies of scale. | 3. Organic farms in Auroville the farms are on the whole small and therefore cannot take advantage of mechanisation and the associated economies of scale. | ||
4. Government subsidies are greater for modern farming than for organic farming as they often involve fertilizers and pesticides which organic farmers do not use. Such subsidies are often used to keep the price of food artificially low. | 4. Government subsidies are greater for modern farming than for organic farming as they often involve fertilizers and pesticides which organic farmers do not use. Such subsidies are often used to keep the price of food artificially low. | ||
When you buy organically produced food you pay the real cost of producing food. This means that you pay the cost not only of food production but also of sustaining the soil and water so that food production to continue. Organic food costs you more money but it doesn’t cost the earth. | When you buy organically produced food you pay the real cost of producing food. This means that you pay the cost not only of food production but also of sustaining the soil and water so that food production to continue. Organic food costs you more money but it doesn’t cost the earth. | ||
A. WHAT IS ‘MODERN’ FARMING? | A. WHAT IS ‘MODERN’ FARMING? | ||
During the latter half of the twentieth century, what is known today as ‘modern’ or ‘industrial’ agriculture was very successful in meeting a growing demand for food by the world's population. This method of farming was developed with two related goals in mind: | During the latter half of the twentieth century, what is known today as ‘modern’ or ‘industrial’ agriculture was very successful in meeting a growing demand for food by the world's population. This method of farming was developed with two related goals in mind: | ||
· to obtain the highest yields possible | · to obtain the highest yields possible | ||
· to get the highest economic profit possible. | · to get the highest economic profit possible. | ||
| Line 23: | Line 23: | ||
In pursuit of these goals, six basic practices have come to form the backbone of modern food production: | In pursuit of these goals, six basic practices have come to form the backbone of modern food production: | ||
· Intensive tillage, where the soil is cultivated deeply with the use of machines. The soil is loosened, water drains better, roots grow faster, and seeds can be planted more easily. Cultivation is also used to control weeds and work dead plant matter into the soil. | · Intensive tillage, where the soil is cultivated deeply with the use of machines. The soil is loosened, water drains better, roots grow faster, and seeds can be planted more easily. Cultivation is also used to control weeds and work dead plant matter into the soil. | ||
· Monoculture, where one crop is grown alone in a (sometimes very large) field. Monoculture makes it easier to cultivate, sow seed, control weeds, and harvest, as well as expand the size of the farm operation and lower unit costs to improve profitability. | · Monoculture, where one crop is grown alone in a (sometimes very large) field. Monoculture makes it easier to cultivate, sow seed, control weeds, and harvest, as well as expand the size of the farm operation and lower unit costs to improve profitability. | ||
· Application of inorganic fertilizer, where very dramatic yield increases occur with the application of synthetic chemical fertilizers. Applied in either liquid or granular form, fertilizers can supply crops with readily available and uniform amounts of essential plant nutrients. They are easy to manufacture, mine, transport and can be applied mechanically. | · Application of inorganic fertilizer, where very dramatic yield increases occur with the application of synthetic chemical fertilizers. Applied in either liquid or granular form, fertilizers can supply crops with readily available and uniform amounts of essential plant nutrients. They are easy to manufacture, mine, transport and can be applied mechanically. | ||
· Irrigation, Drawing water from underground wells, building reservoirs and distribution canals, and diverting rivers have improved yields and increased the area of available farm land. Special sprinklers, pumps, and drip systems have greatly improved the efficiency of water applications. | · Irrigation, Drawing water from underground wells, building reservoirs and distribution canals, and diverting rivers have improved yields and increased the area of available farm land. Special sprinklers, pumps, and drip systems have greatly improved the efficiency of water applications. | ||
· Chemical pest control, where used properly, synthetic chemicals have provided an effective, and relatively easy way to limit the spread of pests and weeds. Chemical sprays can quickly respond to pest outbreaks. | · Chemical pest control, where used properly, synthetic chemicals have provided an effective, and relatively easy way to limit the spread of pests and weeds. Chemical sprays can quickly respond to pest outbreaks. | ||
· Genetic manipulation of crop plants, where use of hybrid and GM seeds has led to higher production and easier farming. | · Genetic manipulation of crop plants, where use of hybrid and GM seeds has led to higher production and easier farming. | ||
Each practice is used for its individual contribution to productivity, but when they are all combined in a farming system, each depends on the others and reinforces the need for using the others. | Each practice is used for its individual contribution to productivity, but when they are all combined in a farming system, each depends on the others and reinforces the need for using the others. | ||
But for all the benefits of modern agriculture there are also problems, which has led to questions about the long term sustainability of these methods: | But for all the benefits of modern agriculture there are also problems, which has led to questions about the long term sustainability of these methods: | ||
· Soil degradation because of excessive tilling and use of chemical fertilizers, which do not put organic matter/microbes in the soil. With no organic matter to renew its composition, the soil becomes like dust and more liable to being blown away by the wind. This is particularly the case in tropical areas where the soil is generally more fragile. | · Soil degradation because of excessive tilling and use of chemical fertilizers, which do not put organic matter/microbes in the soil. With no organic matter to renew its composition, the soil becomes like dust and more liable to being blown away by the wind. This is particularly the case in tropical areas where the soil is generally more fragile. | ||
· Chemical pollution of the environment from the use of chemicals for pest control and inorganic fertilizers which leach into the water. This leads to a process (called nitrification) which can lead to the death of all life in stretches of water. Large monocultures are prone to pest outbreaks requiring the continued and sometimes excessive use of chemicals as the pests build up to resistance to it. | · Chemical pollution of the environment from the use of chemicals for pest control and inorganic fertilizers which leach into the water. This leads to a process (called nitrification) which can lead to the death of all life in stretches of water. Large monocultures are prone to pest outbreaks requiring the continued and sometimes excessive use of chemicals as the pests build up to resistance to it. | ||
· Shortage of water due to large-scale irrigation from underground water, streams and lakes has led to more water being used than is being replenished. | · Shortage of water due to large-scale irrigation from underground water, streams and lakes has led to more water being used than is being replenished. | ||
HEALTH AND SAFETY ISSUES | |||
<br> | |||
Given the pressing need for successful food production system to feed an increasing world population there are fears that a failure of one of the crucial links in the agribusiness model could undermine the whole system. A water supply that becomes too polluted or scarce, or pests which cannot be controlled by chemicals, are both factors that could undermine the entire scheme and lead to mass starvation. A response to the seeming un-sustainability of modern farming was the rise of modern organic farming, which began in the early part of the twentieth century. | Given the pressing need for successful food production system to feed an increasing world population there are fears that a failure of one of the crucial links in the agribusiness model could undermine the whole system. A water supply that becomes too polluted or scarce, or pests which cannot be controlled by chemicals, are both factors that could undermine the entire scheme and lead to mass starvation. A response to the seeming un-sustainability of modern farming was the rise of modern organic farming, which began in the early part of the twentieth century. | ||
<br><br>B. WHAT IS ORGANIC FARMING?<br> | <br><br>B. WHAT IS ORGANIC FARMING?<br> | ||
The aim of organic farming is to work with natural processes rather than seeking to dominate them. In practice this means using resources from within the farm and minimising the use of non-renewable natural resources such as the fossil fuel used for the manufacture of fertilisers and pesticides. Organic farming principles also encompass high animal welfare standards, and contribute to the improvement of the farm’s environmental infrastructure. | The aim of organic farming is to work with natural processes rather than seeking to dominate them. In practice this means using resources from within the farm and minimising the use of non-renewable natural resources such as the fossil fuel used for the manufacture of fertilisers and pesticides. Organic farming principles also encompass high animal welfare standards, and contribute to the improvement of the farm’s environmental infrastructure. | ||
<br> | |||
Organic farming vitalizes nature’s biological cycles in: | Organic farming vitalizes nature’s biological cycles in: | ||
<br> | |||
· The soil by building up soil fertility through crop rotation, the use of nitrogen (N) fixation by legumes, enhancing soil organic matter with compost, and avoiding pollution. | · The soil by building up soil fertility through crop rotation, the use of nitrogen (N) fixation by legumes, enhancing soil organic matter with compost, and avoiding pollution. | ||
| Line 69: | Line 69: | ||
· The farm by treating it as a holistic cycle where the different activities of the farm support each other – the dung produced by animals is used for compost which enables the plants to grow and which in turn, partially returns to the animals as food. | · The farm by treating it as a holistic cycle where the different activities of the farm support each other – the dung produced by animals is used for compost which enables the plants to grow and which in turn, partially returns to the animals as food. | ||
<br> | |||
An organic farmer intends to farm in a way that is sustainable. In agriculture this means balancing what is taken from the soil by crops with what is returned to it. To be truly sustainable these inputs should come from within the farm. Or account must be taken of the cost and resources needed to obtain these things from outside the farm. For instance, if manure is obtained from outside the farm the resources required to collect and transport it must be considered. | An organic farmer intends to farm in a way that is sustainable. In agriculture this means balancing what is taken from the soil by crops with what is returned to it. To be truly sustainable these inputs should come from within the farm. Or account must be taken of the cost and resources needed to obtain these things from outside the farm. For instance, if manure is obtained from outside the farm the resources required to collect and transport it must be considered. | ||
<br> | |||
These are the basics of an organic farm but organic farming can be more than just a difference in technique. Often it is based on different holistic views of the world and this has given rise to a number of different organic farming methods. This includes; Biodynamic Farming, Permaculture and Natural Farming all of which are used by Auroville farmers, having been adapted by them to the Auroville environment. | |||
<br> | |||
Priya Vincent | |||
July 2008 | |||
<br> | |||
You can find out more about sustainable farming in the book ‘Hands With the Earth – The Buddha Garden Approach to Sustainable Food Growing’ by Priya Vincent which is available as a free download or print book (you have to pay for the printing and postage) at www.lulu.com/content/2201600 | You can find out more about sustainable farming in the book ‘Hands With the Earth – The Buddha Garden Approach to Sustainable Food Growing’ by Priya Vincent which is available as a free download or print book (you have to pay for the printing and postage) at www.lulu.com/content/2201600 | ||
Revision as of 07:01, 8 August 2008
WHY ORGANICALLY GROWN FOOD IS MORE EXPENSIVE THAN THAT PRODUCED USING CONVENTIONAL FARMING METHODS
1. Generally production costs of organic farming are higher because the techniques of organic/sustainable farming (see below for description of differences between modern and organic farming) are very labour intensive. Jobs like weeding and compost making are difficult to mechanise. The extra volumes of organic fertilizers needed add to the cost. Whereas a conventional farmer will use 80 –100kg of fertilizer per acre, all of which has been produced in the factory, the organic farmer will need 5 tons of compost per acre, all of which will need to be made on the farm. This means that labour costs are much higher for organic farmers. Organic farmers conserve the soil and water and this takes more labour (in the case of soil) and more infrastructure (various types of irrigation) in the case of water.
2. Production is generally lower on organic farms than on conventional farms especially in the beginning. Research in Buddha Garden and elsewhere shows that plants on organic farms can produce equivalent amounts to those on conventional farms, but the labour needed to keep production at a high level (especially in sustaining the soil) is much more.
3. Organic farms in Auroville the farms are on the whole small and therefore cannot take advantage of mechanisation and the associated economies of scale.
4. Government subsidies are greater for modern farming than for organic farming as they often involve fertilizers and pesticides which organic farmers do not use. Such subsidies are often used to keep the price of food artificially low.
When you buy organically produced food you pay the real cost of producing food. This means that you pay the cost not only of food production but also of sustaining the soil and water so that food production to continue. Organic food costs you more money but it doesn’t cost the earth.
A. WHAT IS ‘MODERN’ FARMING?
During the latter half of the twentieth century, what is known today as ‘modern’ or ‘industrial’ agriculture was very successful in meeting a growing demand for food by the world's population. This method of farming was developed with two related goals in mind:
· to obtain the highest yields possible
· to get the highest economic profit possible.
In pursuit of these goals, six basic practices have come to form the backbone of modern food production:
· Intensive tillage, where the soil is cultivated deeply with the use of machines. The soil is loosened, water drains better, roots grow faster, and seeds can be planted more easily. Cultivation is also used to control weeds and work dead plant matter into the soil.
· Monoculture, where one crop is grown alone in a (sometimes very large) field. Monoculture makes it easier to cultivate, sow seed, control weeds, and harvest, as well as expand the size of the farm operation and lower unit costs to improve profitability.
· Application of inorganic fertilizer, where very dramatic yield increases occur with the application of synthetic chemical fertilizers. Applied in either liquid or granular form, fertilizers can supply crops with readily available and uniform amounts of essential plant nutrients. They are easy to manufacture, mine, transport and can be applied mechanically.
· Irrigation, Drawing water from underground wells, building reservoirs and distribution canals, and diverting rivers have improved yields and increased the area of available farm land. Special sprinklers, pumps, and drip systems have greatly improved the efficiency of water applications.
· Chemical pest control, where used properly, synthetic chemicals have provided an effective, and relatively easy way to limit the spread of pests and weeds. Chemical sprays can quickly respond to pest outbreaks.
· Genetic manipulation of crop plants, where use of hybrid and GM seeds has led to higher production and easier farming.
Each practice is used for its individual contribution to productivity, but when they are all combined in a farming system, each depends on the others and reinforces the need for using the others.
But for all the benefits of modern agriculture there are also problems, which has led to questions about the long term sustainability of these methods:
· Soil degradation because of excessive tilling and use of chemical fertilizers, which do not put organic matter/microbes in the soil. With no organic matter to renew its composition, the soil becomes like dust and more liable to being blown away by the wind. This is particularly the case in tropical areas where the soil is generally more fragile.
· Chemical pollution of the environment from the use of chemicals for pest control and inorganic fertilizers which leach into the water. This leads to a process (called nitrification) which can lead to the death of all life in stretches of water. Large monocultures are prone to pest outbreaks requiring the continued and sometimes excessive use of chemicals as the pests build up to resistance to it.
· Shortage of water due to large-scale irrigation from underground water, streams and lakes has led to more water being used than is being replenished.
HEALTH AND SAFETY ISSUES
Given the pressing need for successful food production system to feed an increasing world population there are fears that a failure of one of the crucial links in the agribusiness model could undermine the whole system. A water supply that becomes too polluted or scarce, or pests which cannot be controlled by chemicals, are both factors that could undermine the entire scheme and lead to mass starvation. A response to the seeming un-sustainability of modern farming was the rise of modern organic farming, which began in the early part of the twentieth century.
B. WHAT IS ORGANIC FARMING?
The aim of organic farming is to work with natural processes rather than seeking to dominate them. In practice this means using resources from within the farm and minimising the use of non-renewable natural resources such as the fossil fuel used for the manufacture of fertilisers and pesticides. Organic farming principles also encompass high animal welfare standards, and contribute to the improvement of the farm’s environmental infrastructure.
Organic farming vitalizes nature’s biological cycles in:
· The soil by building up soil fertility through crop rotation, the use of nitrogen (N) fixation by legumes, enhancing soil organic matter with compost, and avoiding pollution.
· The crop by using varieties that grow well in the climate and soil conditions of the farm and are resistant to pests.
· The livestock by keeping animals in a humane manner that enables them to fully express their instinctive activities as well as building up their natural immunity to diseases.
· The farm by treating it as a holistic cycle where the different activities of the farm support each other – the dung produced by animals is used for compost which enables the plants to grow and which in turn, partially returns to the animals as food.
An organic farmer intends to farm in a way that is sustainable. In agriculture this means balancing what is taken from the soil by crops with what is returned to it. To be truly sustainable these inputs should come from within the farm. Or account must be taken of the cost and resources needed to obtain these things from outside the farm. For instance, if manure is obtained from outside the farm the resources required to collect and transport it must be considered.
These are the basics of an organic farm but organic farming can be more than just a difference in technique. Often it is based on different holistic views of the world and this has given rise to a number of different organic farming methods. This includes; Biodynamic Farming, Permaculture and Natural Farming all of which are used by Auroville farmers, having been adapted by them to the Auroville environment.
Priya Vincent
July 2008
You can find out more about sustainable farming in the book ‘Hands With the Earth – The Buddha Garden Approach to Sustainable Food Growing’ by Priya Vincent which is available as a free download or print book (you have to pay for the printing and postage) at www.lulu.com/content/2201600