Residents Assembly Service: Difference between revisions

From Auroville Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
No edit summary
No edit summary
Line 1: Line 1:
The "Residents' Assembly Service" was approved by the Residents Assembly in August 2007 and constituted on 1 November 2007 for a term of two years.<br> <br>
==== Timings and Location(s)  ====


== Residents' Assembly Service ==
==== General Information and Background ====


We are:
The Residents Assembly Service was approved by the Residents Assembly in August 2007 and constituted on 1 November 2007 for a term of two years.<br>


[mailto:rolfartist@auroville.org.in Rolf]
==== Members and Affiliations  ====


[mailto:aravind@auroville.org.in Anbu]
==== Aims and Objectives  ====


[mailto:amy@auroville.org.in Amy]
It is with regret that the present members of the RA Service (Anbu, Rolf, Amy) submit to you their intention to resign. To illuminate our reasons, we'll try to explain here, in black and white (although the matter is really many shades of grey): 1. From our perspective, the "Residents’ Assembly" as indicated in the Auroville Foundation Act, does not exist as a decision-making entity. Therefore, we feel that to be a 'Residents’ Assembly Service' is a misnomer. Our experience has us asking the question, "How do we provide a 'service' to a Residents’ Assembly which does not functionally exist?" 2. Of the estimated 1,450 Residents’ Assembly adults, on a 'good' day a maximum of 80 residents participate in a meeting (=6%). This simply is not enough participation. The work involved in organizing meetings which include many communications and information exchanges can be tremendous. To have a few Residents’ Assembly members respond to any particular matter does not justify the work especially in light of the fact that the working groups (namely the Auroville Council and the Working Committee) do not recognize participation of a few Residents’ Assembly members; it seems that it's only the numbers that count. 3. In the 8 to 9 months experience of a functioning RA Service, we received only 2 or 3 e-mails / letters from concerned residents, despite repeated invitation to contact us for inquiries or feedback. Since there seem to be no general concerns and the RA is happy with things as they are, we don’t see the need for a RA Service to address these concerns of 0.2&nbsp;% of the RA, neither will it be taken serious by the working groups. 4. Working Group’s collaboration with the RA Service was next to nil. Inquiries were not answered, our mails were not acknowledged and information was not shared with us. Non-support and disrespect was the general experience. Any attempts to improve the functioning of our organization or clarity in the processes were considered irrelevant and non-important. However, since we are currently facilitating a community discussion around the matter of land sale and exchange we will wait until this process reaches a conclusion, there upon we will cease operating as the RA Service. Obviously, if the Residents’ Assembly wishes to retain this service, new members should be sought. However, we invite the community to consider first how it might become more involved in the decision-making process. Otherwise, if nothing changes, well then ... nothing changes. If the Residents’ Assembly wishes to discuss this matter in person, we are open to a dialogue. You need to let us know if you want / need any further illumination in this matter.<br> Check out the latest news related to the [http://www.auroville.org.in/announcementdetailgroup.php?antid=4870 RA Service]
 
Please do not hesitate to [mailto:raservice@auroville.org.in contact] us at
 
We are here for YOU.
 
Check out the latest news related to the [http://www.auroville.org.in/announcementdetailgroup.php?antid=4870 RAS]
 
Dear Community,
 
 
It is with regret that the present members of the RA Service (Anbu, Rolf, Amy) submit to you their intention to resign. To illuminate our reasons, we'll try to explain here, in black and white (although the matter is really many shades of grey):
1. From our perspective, the "Residents’ Assembly" as indicated in the Auroville Foundation Act, does not exist as a decision-making entity. Therefore, we feel that to be a 'Residents’ Assembly Service' is a misnomer. Our experience has us asking the question, "How do we provide a 'service' to a Residents’ Assembly which does not functionally exist?"
2. Of the estimated 1,450 Residents’ Assembly adults, on a 'good' day a maximum of 80 residents participate in a meeting (=6%). This simply is not enough participation. The work involved in organizing meetings which include many communications and information exchanges can be tremendous. To have a few Residents’ Assembly members respond to any particular matter does not justify the work especially in light of the fact that the working groups (namely the Auroville Council and the Working Committee) do not recognize participation of a few Residents’ Assembly members; it seems that it's only the numbers that count.
3. In the 8 to 9 months experience of a functioning RA Service, we received only 2 or 3 e-mails / letters from concerned residents, despite repeated invitation to contact us for inquiries or feedback. Since there seem to be no general concerns and the RA is happy with things as they are, we don’t see the need for a RA Service to address these concerns of 0.2 % of the RA, neither will it be taken serious by the working groups.
 
4. Working Group’s collaboration with the RA Service was next to nil. Inquiries were not answered, our mails were not acknowledged and information was not shared with us. Non-support and disrespect was the general experience. Any attempts to improve the functioning of our organization or clarity in the processes were considered irrelevant and non-important.
 
 
However, since we are currently facilitating a community discussion around the matter of land sale and exchange we will wait until this process reaches a conclusion, thereupon we will cease operating as the RA Service.
 
Obviously, if the Residents’ Assembly wishes to retain this service, new members should be sought. However, we invite the community to consider first how it might become more involved in the decision-making process. Otherwise, if nothing changes, well then ... nothing changes.
 
If the Residents’ Assembly wishes to discuss this matter in person, we are open to a dialogue. You need to let us know if you want / need any further illumination in this matter.
 
Sincerely,
Anbu, Rolf and Amy
RA Service

Revision as of 16:19, 9 January 2009

Timings and Location(s)

General Information and Background

The Residents Assembly Service was approved by the Residents Assembly in August 2007 and constituted on 1 November 2007 for a term of two years.

Members and Affiliations

Aims and Objectives

It is with regret that the present members of the RA Service (Anbu, Rolf, Amy) submit to you their intention to resign. To illuminate our reasons, we'll try to explain here, in black and white (although the matter is really many shades of grey): 1. From our perspective, the "Residents’ Assembly" as indicated in the Auroville Foundation Act, does not exist as a decision-making entity. Therefore, we feel that to be a 'Residents’ Assembly Service' is a misnomer. Our experience has us asking the question, "How do we provide a 'service' to a Residents’ Assembly which does not functionally exist?" 2. Of the estimated 1,450 Residents’ Assembly adults, on a 'good' day a maximum of 80 residents participate in a meeting (=6%). This simply is not enough participation. The work involved in organizing meetings which include many communications and information exchanges can be tremendous. To have a few Residents’ Assembly members respond to any particular matter does not justify the work especially in light of the fact that the working groups (namely the Auroville Council and the Working Committee) do not recognize participation of a few Residents’ Assembly members; it seems that it's only the numbers that count. 3. In the 8 to 9 months experience of a functioning RA Service, we received only 2 or 3 e-mails / letters from concerned residents, despite repeated invitation to contact us for inquiries or feedback. Since there seem to be no general concerns and the RA is happy with things as they are, we don’t see the need for a RA Service to address these concerns of 0.2 % of the RA, neither will it be taken serious by the working groups. 4. Working Group’s collaboration with the RA Service was next to nil. Inquiries were not answered, our mails were not acknowledged and information was not shared with us. Non-support and disrespect was the general experience. Any attempts to improve the functioning of our organization or clarity in the processes were considered irrelevant and non-important. However, since we are currently facilitating a community discussion around the matter of land sale and exchange we will wait until this process reaches a conclusion, there upon we will cease operating as the RA Service. Obviously, if the Residents’ Assembly wishes to retain this service, new members should be sought. However, we invite the community to consider first how it might become more involved in the decision-making process. Otherwise, if nothing changes, well then ... nothing changes. If the Residents’ Assembly wishes to discuss this matter in person, we are open to a dialogue. You need to let us know if you want / need any further illumination in this matter.
Check out the latest news related to the RA Service